Thursday, February 9, 2012

Video Mocks Google's Privacy Practices

September 2, 2010

Consumer Watchdog has launched a rather unique effort in its bid to highlight its concerns over Google's privacy policies and to push Congress to allow consumers to opt out of having their Web activities tracked by online firms.

The group has launched a 540-square-foot animated ad, which is running twice an hour in New York's Times Square, promoting a cartoon video that mocks Google's privacy practices by showing the firm's CEO Eric Schmidt offering free ice cream to children while he secretly collects information about them. The public interest group has been a loud and frequent critic of Google, launching a Web site focused on the Internet giant called Inside Google.

In the cartoon video, Schmidt is seen driving around in a Google ice cream truck and tells a group of children who run up to get the free ice cream he is offering that, "I already know your favorite flavors. Hold still while we collect some of your secrets. And if there is anything you don't want anyone to know, well you shouldn't be doing it in the first place," the cartoonish Schmidt says with a sinister laugh refrencing a famous quote from the real Google CEO. "Remember kids you can't believe everything your parents say about privacy," as he goes on to tell each child what their parents have been doing on the Web.

The video ends with a voice telling viewers to call Congress and urge lawmakers to establish a "do not track" list. Consumer advocates have promoted the idea of such a list, which would be similar to the FTC's Do-Not-Call Registry aimed at stopping unwanted telemarketing calls, to allow Internet users to block firms from tracking their Web activities. FTC Chairman Jon Leibowitz has said the agency is considering proposing such a list, but it would have to be mandated by Congress.

Schmidt raised eyebrows for comments he made to the Wall Street Journal last month when he suggested that children may want to change their names when they grow up to escape the mistakes of their youth that will have been recorded on social networking sites. He also predicted that Google one day will know so much about its users that they will want the firm "to tell them what they should be doing next."

Google has argued that it allows consumers to protect their privacy by giving them more control over their information with such products as Google Dashboard, which provides users with a control panel for the information they store with their Google accounts, and its ad preferences manager that allows users to edit the categories used to target Internet ads at them or to opt-out of receiving such ads.

Join the Discussion

The National Journal Group has the right (but not the obligation) to monitor the comments and to remove any materials it deems inappropriate.

Comments powered by Disqus

 

Archives

Monthly Archives

Categories

Recent Posts

Recent Comments


Contributors

Juliana Gruenwald

Tech Writer

E-Mail: jgruenwald@nationaljournal.com.


Juliana Gruenwald has been covering tech and telecom issues for more than a decade for National Journal, Interactive Week, BNA and Congressional Quarterly. This is her second stint with National Journal. She was recruited by NJ in 1998 to help launch its first tech policy publication, Technology Daily. She left in 2000 to cover international tech and telecom issues for Ziff Davis Media's Interactive Week magazine. She started her career at United Press International as the wire service's first Helen Thomas Intern. She has a Bachelor of Arts degree from the University of Minnesota. A Minneapolis native, she misses the lakes but not the cold.


Josh Smith

Tech Reporter

E-Mail: joshsmith@nationaljournal.com.


Josh Smith covers technology policy as a staff reporter for National Journal. He previously interned at National Journal Daily, a Senate press office, and the Deseret News in Salt Lake City where he covered the state legislature, courts, and crime. In 2009 he graduated with honors from Southern Utah University after managing an award-winning student newspaper as editor-in-chief. Josh has received state, regional and national awards for his political and policy reporting, including first place in CapitolBeat’s 2009 Best of Statehouse Reporting college competition. A native of drop-dead-gorgeous Utah, Josh lives in Virginia with his wife, Amber.