Google Critic Paid By Microsoft
Telecommunications analyst Scott Cleland, whose work is bankrolled by companies like AT&T, Comcast, and Verizon, also signed on as a hired gun for Microsoft earlier this year, according to a summary of testimony he plans to deliver Thursday at a joint hearing of the House Energy and Commerce Communications Subcommittee and Consumer Protection Subcommittee. The focus of the session is Internet privacy and behavioral advertising. Cleland, a frequent critic of Google, runs Precursor, an industry research and consulting firm, and chairs NetCompetition.org, which he describes as a "a pro-competition e-forum funded by broadband companies."
While Cleland asserts that his testimony reflects his personal views and not the views of his clients, Google sympathizers wonder if his new affiliation with Microsoft might further fuel what they believe is an already staunchly anti-Google agenda. Last December, Precursor issued a report alleging that Google "is by far the largest user of Internet bandwidth," the company's share of bandwidth usage is rising rapidly, and it's bandwidth use "is orders of magnitude greater than its payment for its cost." Google's telecom counsel Richard Whitt responded to the attack, calling the report "payola punditry." Google Associate General Counsel Nicole Wong will testify Thursday, presumably in defense of her firm's practices.
Regardless of who signs Cleland's checks, his testimony concludes that if Congress decides to legislate on Internet privacy, a competition/technology-neutral framework is the way to go. According to Cleland, such a proposal would: emphasize protecting people not technologies; empower consumers with the control/freedom to choose to either protect or exploit their own privacy; prevent competitive arbitrage of asymmetric technology-driven privacy policies with a level playing field; stay current with ever-evolving technological innovation; and accommodate both privacy and public interests by empowering real consumer privacy choice.
Update: Cleland told Tech Daily Dose his work with Microsoft has been focused on Internet security and safety.
Join the Discussion
The National Journal Group has the right (but not the obligation) to monitor the comments and to remove any materials it deems inappropriate.
Comments powered by Disqus