Tuesday, May 22, 2012

When In Doubt, Blame Porn?

April 22, 2008 | 8:49 PM

My reporting on Tuesday's Senate Commerce Committee "Future of the Internet" hearing, which appeared in CongressDaily's PM edition (and Wednesday's AM) was absent one component that has been on my mind all afternoon. So, I thought I'd address it here: the Christian Coalition of America's testimony in favor of "network neutrality" legislation.

The religious group, which relies on Web communications to spread its gospel (and has been an active member of the Save the Internet coalition), could have made a convincing argument in favor of legislation that would bar broadband providers from blocking or filtering legal content that travels on their networks -- but pesky pornography got in the way.

In her testimony, coalition spokeswoman Michelle Combs railed against the adult entertainment industry, alleging that XXX has stayed quiet on net neutrality because "any unsavory producer of content should be worried that its content could be disadvantaged in a non-neutral network." Then she suggested the porn biz "knows that it will be able to pay premium prices to be on the fast lane with exceptional quality of service provided by the cable industry." Huh?

I'm not rushing to porn's defense here nor am I coming out on either side of the net neutrality debate, but I would imagine that some legitimate adult content producers are a wee bit worried about a climate, regardless of its probability, where content that is deemed "inappropriate" could be blocked by the pipeline provider at the flip of a switch.

I don’t know whether the porn lobby has weighed in on net neutrality but I'll be sure to ask. In the meantime, maybe Combs should fine-tune her talking points.

Join the Discussion

The National Journal Group has the right (but not the obligation) to monitor the comments and to remove any materials it deems inappropriate.

Comments powered by Disqus

 

Search This Blog
Archives

Monthly Archives

Categories

Recent Posts

Recent Comments


Contributors

Juliana Gruenwald

Tech Writer

E-Mail: jgruenwald@nationaljournal.com.


Juliana Gruenwald has been covering tech and telecom issues for more than a decade for National Journal, Interactive Week, BNA and Congressional Quarterly. This is her second stint with National Journal. She was recruited by NJ in 1998 to help launch its first tech policy publication, Technology Daily. She left in 2000 to cover international tech and telecom issues for Ziff Davis Media's Interactive Week magazine. She started her career at United Press International as the wire service's first Helen Thomas Intern. She has a Bachelor of Arts degree from the University of Minnesota. A Minneapolis native, she misses the lakes but not the cold.


Josh Smith

Tech Reporter

E-Mail: joshsmith@nationaljournal.com.


Josh Smith covers technology policy as a staff reporter for National Journal. He previously interned at National Journal Daily, a Senate press office, and the Deseret News in Salt Lake City where he covered the state legislature, courts, and crime. In 2009 he graduated with honors from Southern Utah University after managing an award-winning student newspaper as editor-in-chief. Josh has received state, regional and national awards for his political and policy reporting, including first place in CapitolBeat’s 2009 Best of Statehouse Reporting college competition. A native of drop-dead-gorgeous Utah, Josh lives in Virginia with his wife, Amber.